The court did not satisfy the unfounded claim
On November 25, 2013, January 27, 2014, July 04, 2014, September 03, 2014 in Almaty, the district court No. 2 of Almaly district considered lawsuits and issued decisions on the statements of the authors Mustapaev B.K., Aitimbetov A.K., Usmanov S.Kh., Abdiraimov A.B., misled and instigated by the head of the NGO The "Union of Songwriters" N.M. Enzhanov filed lawsuits about the illegality and invalidity of the concluded agreements of the NGO KazAK with the authors, although they are not members of KazAK. Following the consideration of the claims, the courts ruled to dismiss the claims of Mustapaev B.K., Aitimbetov A.K., Usmanov S.Kh., Abdiraimov A.B. in full. Thereby recognizing the illegality and baselessness of the presented arguments and statements of the plaintiffs. The Appellate and Cassation judicial boards of the Almaty City Court dated March 14, 2014, April 18, 2014, June 19, 2014, and August 29, 2014, having considered the plaintiffs' complaints against the decisions of the courts of first instance, recognized their legality and the correctness of the application of substantive and procedural legislation, left them unchanged, and dismissed the complaint.